RPG a Day 2016 Day 28

RPG a Day 2016: “I find your lack of good taste disturbing” – Day 28


And here we are just three days away from the end of #RPGaDay 2016. Ok so I cheated by covering days 1, 2 and 3 in one post and then  21, 22, 23 and 24 in another, but hey, I’ve written on all of the themes for this year so far. Let’s not drop the ball now. It is so kind of you to come around Sunday; let’s get on with the topic at hand.

August 28: What film or novel would you be most surprised that a friend had not seen or read?

Here is what the RPG a Day 2016 topic list says about today’s question: “We all have ‘shelves of shame’ full of books or films we want to read or watch, but have not. What would you be most surprised to learn that a person in your game group had not seen or read?”

I like the concept! “Shelves of shame” of books or films we haven’t gotten around to reading or watching. I can certainly empathize, definitely going to use that again. This is a curious question because if I had answered it fifteen or twenty years ago it would have been easier. As far as books go The Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings, movies would be Star Wars and Conan. These days, well it’s not so cut and dry; let me tell you why…

Vader's Taste

Role Playing Games are 42 years old, me I’ve been gaming for 30, the RPG hobby had existed for twelve years before I began playing, but back then there was still a shared experience, many of us read or watched the same stuff. Most read Tolkien’s works, many read Howard’s Conan stories. Star Wars is still a cultural landmark, but back then there were no DVDs or many other media properties tied in to the franchise, the hardcore fans shared a different experience of the movies than the casual moviegoer.

But the thing is, our geek culture exploded into the mainstream, video games, TV, movies, they all share with the masses what we enjoyed in our little niche group. Superheroes, fantasy, and science fiction shows, movies and games are all the rage now. We can’t even keep up with everything. What are some of the most popular shows on TV? TV series based on a comic book about the zombie apocalypse and another one based on a fantasy book series. Thirteen year old me would not have believed it if you told him!

I’m not one to lament that fact. Some people bemoan that what we loved is now the norm. On the contrary I am glad! But it does mean that when I sit down to play a game I can’t assume the other gamers at the table enjoy the same books or movies I do. Of course there are some common ones. Most people have seen the LotR trilogy, not so much read the books; Star Wars also, but there are gamers who grew up with the prequels and don’t find them as abhorrent as we old timers do, and most have not only watched the movies but played video games set in that universe. The Marvel movies seem ubiquitous. Some RPG players came to the game from console or computer gaming unlike us who went from the tabletop to the electronic dungeon. A whole generation grew up reading Harry Potter, watching the movies, while I’ve only seen a few of the films and never read the books.

Diversity is a good thing! It just means more varied experiences and expectations at the gaming table. So I try not to judge and not to preconceive. Not having seen the big ones I mention above might take me aback. I’d be really surprised if a friend hasn’t seen the Lord of the Ring movies, at least a few Marvel movies and most likely Harry Potter. I think many in the younger generation have read Potter, more than Tolkien these days. But I would not be surprised if a friend tells me that the main impetus for them to play an RPG is because they played Final Fantasy X, Y or Z. Or that someone knows about Cthulhu because of a video game, not because they read Lovecraft. And that’s ok; I won’t judge them for it!

Diversity is a great thing, and we should to embrace it in our games. Don’t judge someone because of what they have or haven’t read or watched. Whether they LARP, their gender, sexual preference, or their favorite game for that matter! We’re all one big family of gamers, and I’m happy to be here with all of you. What an amazing time, it’s cool to be a gamer… We’ve all come out of the basements and into the light!

Well what do you think? Let us know what you think in the comments. Enjoy the rest of the weekend. See you tomorrow for the antepenultimate post of RPG a Day 2016.

4 thoughts on “RPG a Day 2016: “I find your lack of good taste disturbing” – Day 28”

  1. I agree that diversity is a good thing. In my current gaming groups there’s definitely a generation gap between those of us in our 40s and those in their 20s.

    Middle-aged Gen Xers remember the early waves of popularity of fantasy and role-playing games, while Millennials grew up in a world where superhero movies and videogames are mainstream.

    I have to remind myself and my peers not to dump too much nostalgia on the younger folks. It’s true that 80% of content in any time period isn’t very good, but if I can appreciate Forbidden Planet (a movie before my time), I hope that they can appreciate Blade Runner.

    By the same token, it’s worth keeping up with current trends and keeping an open mind. Well-made, influential, and fun movies and games have been made both before 1990 and after it!

    There’s a difference between personal preference — I fully admit to liking four-color comics, pulpy space opera, and heroic fantasy over other subgenres — and understanding enduring works that everyone should know.

    If someone learns of Homer’s Illiad from anime or eventually learns that Twilight is a descendant of Bram Stoker’s villain, so much the better. Despite Hollywood’s tendency toward “requels,” we all want new, original entertainment.

    We should be patient and learn from one another while respecting our differences. Just wait until those now in elementary school join us regularly at the game table!

    1. Indeed, wholeheartedly agree! I’m 43, at my table the age range is mostly 44 to 34 with 2 players in their mid 20s. I live the generational mix and the different perspective they bring to the table. Also the gender mix is 3 females, 5 males which is also a good mix.

  2. My gaming table is aged 48 to 51 and I am the youngest. I am also the only non-wargamer and I don’t like Lord of hte Rings or Star Wars. Amongst my players there is pretty much a monoculture of cultural references but that is fine they all have a shared background and like you say above it was before DVD and partly even before video tapes so sharing books was the way we all had access to a lot of these works like the Conan books. I remember everyone going mad for David Eddings and the Elf Stones of Shanara as well while I was at school.

    1. I’m not sure warhammer and curiously although one or two of my players might have dabbled in Warhammer, there are no hardcore war gamers. While I did enjoy Dragonlance way back when I was never one to read every novel TSR put out and was put off by the sheer ammount. Was never really into game related fiction. To this day my reading taste is not generally gaming related. Wait just you don’t like LOTS or Star Wars? Why am I even replying to you…

      Just kidding man, good to read you on a Monday!

Leave a Reply